| October · 7 sales · median $0 · — vs Sep |
| 31 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −12% | $0 |
| 24 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | — | $1 |
| 18 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +150% | $1 |
| 14 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −51% | $0 |
| 11 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −40% | $0 |
| 6 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +353% | $1 |
| 5 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +7% | $0 |
| September · 7 sales · median $0 · +47% vs Aug |
| 28 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −44% | $0 |
| 27 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −55% | $0 |
| 25 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +124% | $1 |
| 22 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −47% | $0 |
| 14 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −53% | $0 |
| 7 | eBay | Pupitar - 42/124 - Uncommon (Near Mint) XY Fates Collide - Fighting Pokémon 42/124 | +125% | $1 |
| 1 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −62% | $0 |
| August · 8 sales · median $0 · −2% vs Jul |
| 24 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +113% | $1 |
| 24 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +57% | $1 |
| 22 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +192% | $0 |
| 18 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +33% | $0 |
| 9 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −40% | $0 |
| 8 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −40% | $0 |
| 5 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −82% | $0 |
| 1 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon Fates Collide Pokemon Near Mint 42/124 | +914% | $1 |
| July · 8 sales · median $0 · −70% vs Jun |
| 27 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −68% | $0 |
| 25 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +193% | $0 |
| 23 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −64% | $0 |
| 19 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −74% | $0 |
| 17 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon Fates Collide Pokemon NM 42/124 | +960% | $2 |
| 12 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −79% | $0 |
| 10 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +268% | $1 |
| 7 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −75% | $0 |
| June · 6 sales · median $1 · +186% vs May |
| 28 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | +1400% | $1 |
| 26 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −96% | $0 |
| 26 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon Fates Collide Pokemon Near Mint 42/124 | −37% | $1 |
| 25 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Fates Collide English Pokemon Card TCG 42/124 | +255% | $2 |
| 25 | TCGplayer | Pupitar #42 Near Mint English | −78% | $1 |
| 2 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Fates Collide Uncommon Pokemon NM 42/124 | +617% | $3 |
| May · 1 sale · median $0 · −74% vs Apr |
| 22 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Fates Collide Uncommon Regular Stage 1 80 HP Thrash Pokémon TCG 42/124 | −82% | $0 |
| April · 2 sales · median $1 · −9% vs Feb |
| 20 | eBay | Pokemon - Pupitar - Fates Collide - Card 42/124 42/124 | +176% | $2 |
| 9 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 - XY - Fates Collide Pokémon Uncommon LP 42/124 | −27% | $1 |
| February · 2 sales · median $1 · +51% vs Jan |
| 22 | eBay | Pokemon TCG XY - Fates Collide Pupitar 42/124 42/124 | −50% | $1 |
| 20 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 LP Fates Collide English Pokemon Card TCG 42/124 | +101% | $2 |
| January · 1 sale · median $1 · — vs Dec |
| 26 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Pokemon XY - Fates Collide Uncommon 42/124 | — | $1 |
| December 2025 · 1 sale · median $1 · −27% vs Jun |
| 28 | eBay | Pokémon TCG Fates Collide Pupitar #42 42/124 | −27% | $1 |
| June 2025 · 1 sale · median $1 · −32% vs Apr |
| 12 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Pokemon Trading Card - Fates Collide - Near Mint | −9% | $1 |
| April 2025 · 3 sales · median $2 · +55% vs Mar |
| 30 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon - Pokemon XY Fates Collide Card | −26% | $1 |
| 24 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Holo - Fates Collide - Pokemon Card 42/124 | +1% | $2 |
| 8 | eBay | Pupitar Pokémon Card TCG Pokemon XY Fates Collide 42/124 42/124 | +58% | $2 |
| March 2025 · 2 sales · median $1 · +482% vs Dec |
| 18 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Holo - Fates Collide - Pokemon Card 42/124 | −3% | $1 |
| 10 | eBay | Pokemon Pupitar 42/124 Fates Collide Uncommon Basic Fighting TCG Card 42/124 | +491% | $1 |
| December 2024 · 1 sale · median $0 · — vs Sep |
| 30 | eBay | New: 2016 Pokémon TCG Pupitar Fates Collide 42 Regular Uncommon #42 | — | $0 |
| September 2024 · 1 sale · median $0 · −80% vs Aug |
| 21 | eBay | New: 2016 Pokémon TCG Pupitar Fates Collide 42 Regular Uncommon #42 | −68% | $0 |
| August 2024 · 2 sales · median $1 · −39% vs May |
| 26 | eBay | Pokemon TCG XY Fates Collide Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon - Brand New Genuine 42/124 | −55% | $1 |
| 26 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Holo - Fates Collide - Pokemon Card 42/124 | −6% | $2 |
| May 2024 · 2 sales · median $2 · +50% vs Apr |
| 25 | eBay | Pokemon Card Pupitar 42/124 XY Fates Collide Ultra Rare LP 2016 42/124 | −20% | $2 |
| 7 | eBay | 2016 Pokemon Card Fates Collide Pupitar 42/124 #124 | +67% | $2 |
| April 2024 · 1 sale · median $1 · +13% vs Jan |
| 7 | eBay | Pokemon Card Pupitar 42/124 XY Fates Collide Ultra Rare LP 2016 42/124 | +61% | $1 |
| January 2024 · 2 sales · median $1 · −26% vs Dec |
| 14 | eBay | Pokemon XY Fates Collide, Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon, Mint, | −46% | $1 |
| 2 | eBay | Pupitar 42/124 Uncommon | XY: Fates Collide | Pokemon Card | −12% | $1 |
| December 2023 · 2 sales · median $1 |
| 31 | eBay | Pokemon Card Pupitar 42/124 XY Fates Collide Ultra Rare TCG 42/124 | +20% | $2 |
| 24 | eBay | PUPITAR FATES COLLIDE SET POKEMON CARD 42/124 LP | — | $1 |