Raw, it’s a $1.40 card. Slabbed as a CGC 10 Pristine it sells for 38× that.
| July · 2 sales · median $53 · −25% vs Aug | ||||
| 30 | eBay | Pokemon Caterpie 56/112 from Fire Red Leaf Green in a CGC Pristine 10 !! 56/112 | +198% | $79.00 |
| 16 | eBay | 2004 Pokémon Caterpie EX Fire Red & Leaf Green #56 CGC PRISTINE 10 56/112 | −62% | $26.51 |
| August 2025 · 1 sale · median $70 · +112% vs May | ||||
| 28 | eBay | (POP 2) CGC 10 PRISTINE Pokemon Caterpie 56/112 EX Fire Red Leaf Green Card 2004 #56 | +112% | $70.00 |
| May 2025 · 1 sale · median $33 | ||||
| 19 | eBay | Caterpie Non-Holo 2004 Pokemon Card 56/112 Fire Red Leaf Green CGC 10 PRISTINE | — | $33.00 |