Raw, it’s a $22.00 card. Slabbed as a PSA 10 it sells for 43× that.
| October · 2 sales · median $1,025 · +26% vs Sep | |||||
| 27 | eBay | 2004 Pokemon Fire Red Leaf Green Magikarp #67 Incorrect Rarity PSA 10 Gem Mint 67/112 | +16% | $1,100 | |
| 11 | eBay | 2004 Pokemon Fire Red Leaf Green Magikarp #67 Incorrect Rarity PSA 10 Gem Mint 67/112 | +17% | $950 | |
| September · 2 sales · median $813 · +54% vs Feb | |||||
| 10 | eBay | 2004 POKEMON EX FIRE RED & LEAF GREEN INCORRECT RARITY #67 MAGIKARP PSA 10 #67 | −1% | $810 | |
| 10 | eBay | 2004 POKEMON EX MAGIKARP RG-INCORRECT RARITY FIRE RED & LEAF GREEN #67 PSA 10 #67 | +55% | $815 | |
| February · 1 sale · median $526 · +2% vs Aug | |||||
| 6 | eBay | 2004 POKEMON EX FIRE RED & LEAF GREEN INCORRECT RARITY #67 MAGIKARP PSA 10 #67 | +2% | $526 | |
| August 2025 · 1 sale · median $515 | |||||
| 3 | eBay | Pokemon Magikarp EX Fire Red & Leaf Green #67 INCORRECT RARITY PSA 10 | — | $515 | |